Is it halachically permissible for an observant homosexual/lesbian couple to adopt a child and raise him or her as a Jew in accordance with Jewish tradition?
As a follow-up question, is it halachically permissible for a Jewish school to refuse to admit the children of a homosexual/lesbian couple even though such school readily admits children of homes that are not Shabbat observant.
There are many questions in this teshuva: what is our response to homosexuals/lesbians, who is a Jew, what are the parameters required to be Shomer Shabbat in the modern world? But the true theme should be in responding to the "follow-up" question: in focusing on the individual; namely, the child who needs education to grow as a knowledgable Jew. We discuss the fine points of the status of gays and lesbians within the Jewish community. But in so doing, we too often lose sight of the individual. A Jew should not be defined by his or her sexuality, but rather by his affiliation as a Jew. Ezekiel is told by G-d that the proverb stating that the parent eats sour grapes and the child's teeth are set on edge should not be used "by Israel any more" (18:1-3) No human should be defined, rewarded or punished by the choices of the parent or life mate. Focusing on the parent as to whether they "can" or "should" overlooks the fact that in our world, parents "do". And we, as a community, are responsible to raise generations of literate Jews.Upon birth, we are no longer ubar erech imo (literally: part of the thigh of the mother). We become individualized. And therefore responsible for our own selves. In recognition of that, we, as a Jewish community, are responsible to educate every Jew.
This is a very sensitive matter. As you know, the Torah law clearly prohibits homosexuality, so use of the term "observant" for the couple is problematic. Adoption from a non-Jewish source requires conversion, for which the Rabbinic Court would want to make sure that the adopting family raises the child in full accord with Jewish tradition, so you can see the difficulty in this.
Insofar as school is concerned, it is difficult to justify schools turning down any Jewish child.
The Conservative Movement has a variety of t’shuvot / responsa on the question of the halakhic status homosexuality. These include papers by Rabbis Bradley Shavit Artson, Elliot Dorff, Joel Roth and Gordon Tucker. I would also recommend the book, Wrestling With God And Men by Rabbi Steven Greenberg, a gay, modern Orthodox rabbi. My position is based on the writings of Rabbi Dorff, a synopsis of whose views can be found in his book, Matters of Life and Death: A Jewish Approach to Modern Medical Ethics, pp. 139 – 151.
Rabbi Dorff writes as follows (p. 141f): “There is no evidence that children growing up with gay or lesbian parents are, as a group, any less well adjusted than children growing up with heterosexual parents… the percentage of children who themselves become homosexual adults does not seem to differ whether the households are headed by homosexual or heterosexual adults… in general two parents, whatever their gender, are better than one.”
In other words, there are no psycho-social reasons to prohibit a homosexual/ lesbian couple from adopting. Nor should there be any Jewish reasons. The question posits that the couple is halakhically observant in their home and wish to give their child(ren) a Torah education. Neither Rabbi Dorff nor I see any objection to such an adoption. Indeed, it should be celebrated for providing a stable and loving home, rooted in Jewish values, to a child.
The second question, about a Jewish school refusing admission to a child of a gay couple makes me shudder! Even should the lay or professional leadership consider homosexuality sinful – and the question as it’s presented, with its mentioning of families that are not shomrei Shabbat, suggests that this is indeed the case – why deprive the children of a Torah education because of the perceived “sins” of the parents?
The prophet Ezekiel asks the rhetorical question, (18:2): “Parents eat sour grapes and their children’s teeth are blunted?” Speaking to the Israelite exiles who were living in Babylonia after the destruction of the First Temple, Ezekiel is saying that children are not punished for the sins of their parents. In his case, the prophet was saying that children are punished for their own sins, not those of their parents. In our case, we can extend the thought of the prophet, as the rabbis surely did, and say that each person and each generation should bear responsibility for his or her own decisions. Even if the leadership of the school considers the behavior of the parents wrong, it is equally wrong to hold the children responsible for the actions of their parents. If the family lives in a community where there is only one Jewish day school, as is often the case, then the leadership of that school would be depriving a child access to a quality Jewish education. That is unconscionable!
Copyright 2020 all rights reserved. Jewish Values Online
N O T I C E
THE VIEWS EXPRESSED IN ANSWERS PROVIDED HEREIN ARE THOSE OF THE INDIVIDUAL JVO PANEL MEMBERS, AND DO NOT
NECESSARILY REFLECT OR REPRESENT THE VIEWS OF THE ORTHODOX, CONSERVATIVE OR REFORM MOVEMENTS, RESPECTIVELY.