A question on Jewish funeral etiquette/proper behavior: What should one do when a funeral lands on the same day as a celebration - a Bar/Bat Mitzvah/wedding/Bris Milah/baby naming, etc.? What if one is a mourner - does that change the answer?
This is a heartbreaking question. You anticipate the up-coming simcha, joyous celebration, only to then find yourself drawn up short by the death of one who is dear to you as a friend or a relative. What a huge emotional conflict one feels when these two occasions – one at the acme of joy and the other at the nadir of sorrow – fall at the same time.
Your question points to a conflict that is spiritual as well as emotional. The Talmud lists both the dowering of the bride and accompanying the dead to the grave among those actions that give one merit in this world and credit in the world to come. We encounter God differently at moments of joy and sorrow, but at the moment you describe the two collide. It is hard to know how to respond.
It is not easy to find answers to your question – most of the responses address events that happen during the days following the funeral, not on the same day. Maurice Lamm in his comprehensive book, The Jewish Way in Death and Mourning, offers some guidance. At the moment of death the direct mourner, the parent, spouse, sibling, or child of the deceased, enters a period known as aninut during which time their only obligation is to care for their loved one. Nonetheless, Lamm notes (pg 177) that halakhah (Jewish law) allows a father to attend the bris of his son even on the day of interment. He also suggests that, since there is a reluctance to ever delay a wedding out of fear that it might undermine the event, a mourner might attend the ceremony but not the celebration if their absence would be significant. While there are moments when a mourner can move between the place of mourning and the place of joy, they need to be clearly exceptional.
The one who is not a mourner certainly has more latitude. I know of no formal or halakhic barrier that would block an individual from attending a funeral and a simcha, such as a naming or a wedding, on the same day. It is unlikely that a Bar or Bat Mitzvah, which usually occurs on Shabbat, would fall on the same day as a funeral.
Whether you ask this question from experience or curiosity, there are times when our joy is met with sorrow. I pray that we may all be spared such occasions.
A question on Jewish funeral etiquette/proper behavior: What should one do when a funeral lands on the same day as a celebration - a Bar/Bat Mitzvah/wedding/Bris Milah/baby naming, etc.? What if one is a mourner - does that change the answer?
Judaism is a religion of legal norms. When norms conflict, the higher grade norm is given preference. Ecclesiastes 7:2 teaches that it is better to attend a mourning situation, where a precept is performed, than a drinking party, which is a non-mandatory and possibly improper act. Ecclesiastes 7:4 observes as description—good advice—and not prescription—an actual rule—that the hearts/minds of the Sages, Israel’s spiritual aristocracy, are in the house of mourning and not the place of revelry.
bMoed Qatan 23a rules that the mourner does not leave thue house for seven days [after burial]. If there is a compelling need or competing commandment, i.e. attending the marriage ceremony, there are grounds for leniency and a rabbi should be consulted because details vary and are important. A Sabbath or Festival bar mitsva must be attended because there is no public mourning on holy days because the public joy overrides private grief.
This question strikes at an essential philosophical question regarding Jewish life: what is more important, celebrating or mourning? Of course, this is a set up that is largely unnecessary since both are deeply important, and ultimately, the rabbinic vision codifies this. But for the sake of teasing this out a bit, it’s worth examining this tension.
In the Bible, Kohelet (not necessarily the voice of optimism) teaches the following: “It is better to go to a house of mourning than to a house of feasting; for that is the end of every man, and a living one should take it to heart. Vexation is better than revelry; for though the face be sad, the heart may be glad. Wise men are drawn to a house of mourning, and fools to a house of merrymaking” (Kohelet 7:2-4). Kohelet is not giving us practical advice here; he is teaching a value. All human beings share one thing: we will all die. Because of this, Kohelet wants us to face this reality rather than deny it. Those who are wise will contemplate the fact that the time we have on this earth is short and attending a house or mourning will remind us of this. In comparison, having fun for its own sake does not have a lasting religious value.
The most stringent case in your question would be a person who is himself a mourner (a spouse, sibling, child, or parent of the deceased). A mourner is permitted to attend the circumcision of his own son, though there are some restrictions on what he is permitted to do at the brit milah. A rabbi should be consulted regarding the differences of custom regarding these specific questions. The ruling for a child’s wedding is similar. Parents (and grandparents too, according to some) are permitted to attend their child’s wedding even if they are sitting shiva. There are restrictions on how much they may celebrate, but there is certainly precedent for such a ruling. For example, Kol Bo Aveilut (a 20th Century rabbi who wrote a compendium of laws regarding mourning) states, “I was chosen to officiate at a wedding, and the brother of the bridegroom’s mother died. It was difficult to postpone the wedding...The mother longed to see her son under the chupah. Likewise the maternal grandmother, who was in mourning for her son, wanted to see her grandson on his day of joy. A few days of their mourning had already passed, and I permitted, after the first three days of mourning, that they should come to the wedding – but only at night, [and] at a time when there was no music or dancing; and they were not allowed to eat or drink there: and they returned home immediately after the seven blessings [recited under the chupah]” (Kol Bo Al Aveilut, p. 272).
All of this assumes that the person about whom you are asking is the mourner. If he is a mourner but the simcha is for someone who is not in his family, he may be permitted to attend the ceremony but not the celebration after. Such a person should consult a rabbi. If the person is not a mourner and he simply has two conflicting events on the same day, one a funeral and one a simcha, there would be no prohibition of which I know to attend both. If he can only attend one, then he should be encouraged to evaluate the relationships that he has with both families and determine where his presence is needed more.
Copyright 2020 all rights reserved. Jewish Values Online
N O T I C E
THE VIEWS EXPRESSED IN ANSWERS PROVIDED HEREIN ARE THOSE OF THE INDIVIDUAL JVO PANEL MEMBERS, AND DO NOT
NECESSARILY REFLECT OR REPRESENT THE VIEWS OF THE ORTHODOX, CONSERVATIVE OR REFORM MOVEMENTS, RESPECTIVELY.
